
The Saint Paul Hotel
Best for travelers seeking a traditional, refined hotel with a long history, formal steakhouse dining, and easy access to St. Paul’s cultural attractions.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Saint Paul Hotel is a historic, 4-star downtown St. Paul landmark for travelers who want classic rooms, formal dining, and easy access to Rice Park and the city’s cultural venues. W Minneapolis The Foshay is a stylish 4.5-star lifestyle hotel inside the landmark Foshay Tower for visitors who prefer modern design, a lively bar scene, and a central Minneapolis arts-and-entertainment location.
Updated

Best for travelers seeking a traditional, refined hotel with a long history, formal steakhouse dining, and easy access to St. Paul’s cultural attractions.

Best for visitors who want a design-forward stay inside an iconic Minneapolis tower and a lively downtown base near theaters, Target Center and Nicollet Mall.
When The Saint Paul Hotel wins: Choose The Saint Paul Hotel if you want a classic, formal hotel experience — historic rooms and a destination steakhouse (The St. Paul Grill), afternoon tea, and easy walking access to Rice Park, the Ordway, Landmark Center and museum attractions in St. Paul.
When W Minneapolis The Foshay wins: Choose W Minneapolis The Foshay if you want modern, lifestyle-focused accommodations in an iconic Minneapolis tower with name recognition, rooftop/landmark views (depending on room), two bars/lounges, and proximity to Minneapolis theaters, Target Center and Nicollet Mall.
Bottom line: Both hotels occupy memorable urban settings; pick The Saint Paul Hotel for tradition, formal dining and straightforward family-friendly service in St. Paul, or pick W Minneapolis The Foshay for a stylish, design-oriented downtown Minneapolis stay with a livelier scene.
| Category | The Saint Paul Hotel | W Minneapolis The Foshay |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic, gracious, historic 4-star hotel with formal public spaces. | Stylish luxury lifestyle hotel inside an Art Deco landmark tower; modern design focus. |
| Location | Overlooks Rice Park in downtown St. Paul; walkable to Ordway, Landmark Center and the river. | Located in downtown Minneapolis at 821 Marquette Ave; steps from Nicollet Mall and the Foshay Tower. |
| Size (rooms) | About 254 rooms and suites. | 229 guestrooms. |
| Built / age | Opened 1910; remodeled 2012 — a long-established historic property. | Housed in the historic Foshay Tower (landmark); modern lifestyle fit-out inside tower. |
| Pools | No pool on property. | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | The St. Paul Grill (refined American steakhouse), The Drake (breakfast/brunch), The Lobby Bar; afternoon tea service is a signature offering. | One on-site restaurant (Manny's Steakhouse listed) plus two bars/lounges and a coffee shop/cafe; cooked-to-order breakfast available (fee). |
| Spa / wellness | No on-property spa; recommends off-site The Darling Den for treatments; 24-hour fitness center available. | Not published |
| Known for | Historic rooms, afternoon tea, The St. Paul Grill steakhouse and event/wedding spaces. | Iconic Foshay Tower location, design-lifestyle branding, proximity to Minneapolis venues and conventions. |
| Accessibility & meetings | Large meeting and wedding capacity (15 event spaces, over 14,000 sq ft) and concierge/valet services. | Conference space ~3080 sq ft with 7 meeting rooms, business center and wedding services. |
| Family / age policy | Family-friendly; children of all ages welcome (minimum check-in age 21 for main guest). | |
The Saint Paul Hotel sits on Rice Park, steps from Landmark Center and the Ordway Center for the Performing Arts.
Choose the Saint Paul Hotel for close access to St. Paul’s cultural institutions and a quieter downtown feel.
W Minneapolis The Foshay is in the Minneapolis core, minutes from Nicollet Mall, theaters and sports venues.
Pick W The Foshay if you want to be in the middle of Minneapolis entertainment and convention activity.
Rooms at The Saint Paul Hotel emphasize traditional finishes and formal comfort across standard, deluxe and suite categories.
The Saint Paul Hotel suits travelers who prefer classic décor, predictable service and full-service hotel amenities.
W Minneapolis The Foshay offers a range of room types from standard 1 King rooms to Urban Suites and a Penthouse in an Art Deco tower.
Choose W The Foshay for rooms with modern design touches and options for high-floor/corner views in a landmark building.
The Saint Paul Hotel centers around The St. Paul Grill and traditional hotel dining, including afternoon tea.
The Saint Paul Hotel is a better fit if a classic steakhouse and formal dining experiences (and afternoon tea) matter to you.
W Minneapolis The Foshay lists Manny’s Steakhouse and a coffee shop plus two bars/lounges for drinks and late-night socializing.
W The Foshay suits travelers who want lively bars and contemporary dining in downtown Minneapolis.
The Saint Paul Hotel’s signature guest experience is afternoon tea and large, flexible event spaces rather than a pool.
If special events, weddings or a formal afternoon tea are priorities, The Saint Paul Hotel is the clearer choice.
W Minneapolis The Foshay’s defining asset is its location inside the Foshay Tower and the lifestyle-hotel programming typical of the W brand.
W The Foshay is best when the landmark-tower setting and downtown Minneapolis scene are the priority.
Wellness at The Saint Paul Hotel centers on a private 24-hour fitness center; nightlife is low-key or centered on hotel dining and the bar.
The Saint Paul Hotel works for travelers who want fitness access and a quieter, family-friendly evening scene.
W Minneapolis The Foshay emphasizes the W-brand nightlife and bar culture alongside fitness and business facilities.
Pick W The Foshay if you prefer a livelier hotel-nightlife atmosphere and downtown Minneapolis evening options.

The Saint Paul Hotel — century-old landmark with formal public rooms, afternoon tea and a long-standing steakhouse.

W Minneapolis The Foshay — stays inside the iconic Foshay Tower and a design-forward W brand experience.

The Saint Paul Hotel — extensive event space (15 rooms, over 14,000 sq ft) and multiple ballrooms for large and small functions.

W Minneapolis The Foshay — immediate access to Nicollet Mall, theater district, Target Center and convention facilities.
The Saint Paul Hotel is explicitly family-friendly and welcomes children of all ages; the Saint Paul setting and casual breakfast/brunch options work well for families.
The Saint Paul Hotel does not have a pool. W Minneapolis The Foshay: pool information is not published in the supplier listing provided.
Both hotels offer prominent steakhouse dining: The Saint Paul Hotel has The St. Paul Grill; W Minneapolis The Foshay lists Manny’s Steakhouse as an on-site restaurant.
Yes. W The Foshay is close to Nicollet Mall, Target Center and Minneapolis theaters; The Saint Paul Hotel is a short walk to Grand Casino Arena and St. Paul venues.
The Saint Paul Hotel does not list an on-property spa but recommends an off-site spa (The Darling Den). W Minneapolis The Foshay spa details are not published in the supplier listing provided.
Explore how The Saint Paul Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·