
The Saint Paul Hotel
Best for formal dining, Rice Park access, and smaller refined weddings and meetings.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Saint Paul Hotel is a historic, refined 4-star hotel overlooking Rice Park in downtown Saint Paul; read this if you want traditional service, formal dining, or a classic venue for meetings and weddings. Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot is a 4-star Marriott in a converted downtown Minneapolis depot complex; read this if you want large event capacity, a central Minneapolis location, and Marriott-brand consistency.
Updated

Best for formal dining, Rice Park access, and smaller refined weddings and meetings.

Best for large conferences, many meeting rooms, and a central Minneapolis base near the river and cultural sites.
When The Saint Paul Hotel wins: choose The Saint Paul Hotel if you prefer a smaller, classic luxury hotel with signature on-site dining (The St. Paul Grill), afternoon tea, a history-rich atmosphere, and intimate event spaces in downtown Saint Paul.
When Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot wins: choose the Renaissance if you need a big event footprint (71,124 sq ft / 23 meeting rooms), on-site indoor pool and fitness facilities open 24 hours, or want to stay inside a restored depot building close to Minneapolis attractions.
Bottom line: both are 4-star historic hotels with strong event offerings; pick The Saint Paul Hotel for refined, traditional downtown Saint Paul lodging and dining, and pick Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot for scale, many meeting rooms, and a central Minneapolis location tied to the riverfront and cultural stops.
| Category | The Saint Paul Hotel | Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Refined, classic historic hotel focused on Rice Park tradition and formal dining. | Full-service Marriott inside a restored depot complex with a mix of modern meeting infrastructure. |
| Location | Overlooks Rice Park in downtown Saint Paul; short walk to Landmark Center and Ordway. | Downtown Minneapolis depot district; within walking distance of Mill Ruins Park, Guthrie Theater, and Stone Arch Bridge. |
| Size (rooms) | 254 rooms (some sources cite 255). | 335 guestrooms. |
| Historic age / building | Opened 1910; large 2012 remodel; member of Preferred Hotels. | Historic train depot complex repurposed as a Marriott hotel. |
| Pools | No on-site pool. | Indoor pool on site. |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site venues including The St. Paul Grill, The Drake, and the Lobby Bar (afternoon tea offered). | Milwaukee Road restaurant + 1 bar/lounge; room service available (limited hours). |
| Spa / treatments | No on-site spa; the hotel recommends an off-site partner (The Darling Den) nearby. | Not published |
| Event & meeting space | Over 14,000 sq ft across 15 event spaces, notable Promenade Ballroom and James J. Hill Room. | About 71,124 sq ft of conference space and 23 meeting rooms, including a ballroom and large banquet halls. |
| Accessibility & mobility | Accessible features and valet parking; private fitness center with 24-hour secure access. | Extensive accessible features listed (accessible parking, accessible meeting spaces, pool hoist, wheelchair-accessible restaurant and registration). |
| Brand & recognition | Independent historic hotel, member of Preferred Hotels; known regionally for The St. Paul Grill and afternoon tea. | Marriott Renaissance brand; large full-service hotel with Marriott systems and rewards. |
The Saint Paul Hotel sits on Market Street overlooking Rice Park, within easy walking reach of Saint Paul cultural landmarks.
Choose The Saint Paul Hotel to stay in Saint Paul’s historic civic core and be steps from Rice Park and nearby performing arts venues.
Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot is in Minneapolis’ downtown depot/riverfront neighborhood, close to theaters and riverfront trails.
Choose the Renaissance for a Minneapolis base near riverfront cultural sites and convenient access to downtown Minneapolis attractions.
The Saint Paul Hotel has a smaller room inventory and a classical room lineup, including suites and executive rooms.
Expect fewer rooms and a more intimate experience at The Saint Paul Hotel, suitable for travelers who prefer a compact, historic property.
Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot offers a larger number of guest rooms and more accessible room-type variety.
The Renaissance gives more room-type options and a larger overall inventory, useful for bigger groups or events needing many rooms.
Dining at The Saint Paul Hotel centers on The St. Paul Grill plus lobby and casual breakfast options.
Pick The Saint Paul Hotel if you want classic steakhouse dining, afternoon tea, and multiple on-site dining venues in a historic setting.
Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot has one main restaurant and a bar/lounge with limited room service hours.
Choose the Renaissance for a straightforward on-site restaurant and bar with convenient service for conference and business travelers.
The Saint Paul Hotel does not have a pool; its signature guest-facing amenity is Afternoon Tea plus a 24-hour fitness center.
If you value afternoon tea and a private 24-hour fitness room over a pool, The Saint Paul Hotel is the match.
Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot includes an indoor pool and 24-hour fitness facilities, combined with very large conference space.
The Renaissance is better when an on-site pool and large, flexible meeting space are priorities.
Saint Paul focuses on classic on-site services with nearby off-site spa options.
Expect traditional service, easy access to nearby spa choices, and refined evening options at The Saint Paul Hotel.
Renaissance provides extensive accessible features and around-the-clock business and fitness services.
Renaissance suits travelers who want robust accessibility features, 24-hour facilities, and quick access to Minneapolis nightlife.

The St. Paul Grill and the hotel’s afternoon tea make The Saint Paul Hotel the better pick for formal dining and traditional experiences.

Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot has about 71,124 sq ft of conference space and 23 meeting rooms, making it the better choice for big events.

Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot includes an on-site indoor pool while The Saint Paul Hotel does not offer a pool area.

The Saint Paul Hotel’s 1910 heritage, smaller room count, and Rice Park setting create a more intimate historic-hotel experience.
Both can host weddings, but for a guest list near 200 consider The Saint Paul Hotel’s James J. Hill Room or Promenade Ballroom; for larger or multiple simultaneous breakout spaces, the Renaissance’s larger total meeting footprint may be easier to stage.
No — The Saint Paul Hotel does not have an on-site pool; the Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot does have an indoor pool.
Both welcome guests of all ages. The Saint Paul Hotel highlights family-friendly breakfast/brunch options at The Drake; Renaissance lists family-friendly room configurations and accessible amenities.
The Saint Paul Hotel does not have an on-site spa but recommends an off-site partner (The Darling Den). Spa services at Renaissance Minneapolis Hotel, The Depot are not published in the supplier listing.
Explore how The Saint Paul Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·