
The Saint Paul Hotel
Best for travelers who want classic, upscale downtown Saint Paul lodging, easy access to Rice Park and cultural venues, and full-service meeting/wedding space.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Saint Paul Hotel is a historic 4-star downtown Saint Paul hotel with classic rooms, a steakhouse (The St. Paul Grill), and extensive meeting/wedding facilities. Hotel Crosby is a popular 2.5-star boutique in Stillwater for visitors who want a small-town riverfront stay — this guide helps travelers choose between a grand city landmark and a regional boutique escape.
Updated

Best for travelers who want classic, upscale downtown Saint Paul lodging, easy access to Rice Park and cultural venues, and full-service meeting/wedding space.

Best for guests wanting a smaller, highly rated boutique stay in Stillwater with rooftop terrace views, a hot tub, and easy access to the Saint Croix River and local attractions.
When The Saint Paul Hotel wins: Choose it for large meetings, wedding receptions, a more formal steakhouse dining option (The St. Paul Grill), and classic downtown location walking distance to Rice Park, the Ordway, Landmark Center and other city venues.
When Hotel Crosby wins: Pick Hotel Crosby for a small-town Stillwater base, a rooftop terrace and hot tub, closer access to the Saint Croix River and local Lowell Park, and a very high guest rating for a boutique property.
Bottom line: If you need a full-service, historic city hotel with substantial event space and refined dining, The Saint Paul Hotel is the clearer pick; if you prefer a compact boutique feel in a scenic river town, Hotel Crosby is the better match.
| Category | The Saint Paul Hotel | Hotel Crosby |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Formal, historic luxury hotel with classic public spaces | Informal boutique with small‑town riverfront character |
| Location | Downtown Saint Paul, overlooks Rice Park; walkable to theaters and museums | Main Street Stillwater, steps from Lowell Park and the Saint Croix River |
| Size (rooms) | 254 rooms (some sources cite 255) | 55 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Star rating | 4.0-star | 2.5-star |
| Guest rating | Well-known positive reviews (multiple sources) | 9.6 (supplier listing) |
| Pools / water features | No pool on property; fitness center available | Hot tub on property; swimming nearby |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: The St. Paul Grill, The Drake, Lobby Bar | Number of restaurants - 1 (name not published) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa (hotel recommends nearby off-site spa — The Darling Den) | Not published |
| Signature amenities | Afternoon Tea, large event and wedding spaces, private 24-hour fitness center | Rooftop terrace, firepit, hot tub, concierge services |
| Parking | Covered valet parking (listed around $40/day) | Free self parking; valet available for a surcharge |
The Saint Paul Hotel sits on Market Street overlooking Rice Park in downtown Saint Paul, close to theaters, museums and the Mississippi River.
Best choice for travelers wanting a central, walkable city location and proximity to Saint Paul attractions.
Hotel Crosby is on Main Street in Stillwater, a short walk from Lowell Park and the Saint Croix River.
A good pick for visitors who want a small-town, walkable riverfront location outside the Twin Cities.
The Saint Paul Hotel offers historic, traditionally furnished rooms and a handful of suites across a large property.
Choose Saint Paul for a wider selection of room types and larger inventory suited to groups and events.
Hotel Crosby has 55 individually decorated guestrooms with a mix of standard rooms, studios and suites.
Hotel Crosby is better if you want a boutique, small‑property room mix with some balcony and suite options.
The Saint Paul Hotel has multiple on-site dining venues including a notable steakhouse and a lobby bar.
The Saint Paul Hotel suits travelers who value a range of formal and casual dining options without leaving the property.
Hotel Crosby lists one on-site restaurant and a bar/lounge for drinks.
Hotel Crosby works well if you want a simple on-site option plus local dining on Stillwater’s Main Street.
The Saint Paul Hotel does not have a pool; its signature guest experience is Afternoon Tea and a private fitness center.
Pick Saint Paul if a pool is not important but you value historic public spaces and signature services like Afternoon Tea.
Hotel Crosby highlights a rooftop terrace and an on-site hot tub as notable recreation features.
Hotel Crosby is preferable when you want a small-property rooftop and easy access to river recreation.
The Saint Paul Hotel provides a secure, well-equipped fitness center and evening bar options in-house.
Good for travelers who want fitness access and refined bar service but not an on-site spa.
Hotel Crosby offers basic concierge and bar service with local nightlife options on Stillwater’s Main Street.
Hotel Crosby fits guests who plan to use local Stillwater dining and pubs rather than hotel nightlife.

The Saint Paul Hotel — extensive event space (over 14,000 sq ft) and multiple ballrooms make it the clear choice for larger events.

Hotel Crosby — small property, high guest rating, rooftop terrace and river access for a compact Stillwater experience.

The Saint Paul Hotel — multiple distinct venues including The St. Paul Grill and The Drake for varied dining occasions.

Hotel Crosby — minutes on foot to the Saint Croix River and Lowell Park; water activities are listed nearby.
Both allow children, but The Saint Paul Hotel has more family-friendly room inventory and dining options; Hotel Crosby is small and boutique-priced for families who prefer a quieter river town.
Neither property lists an on-site pool; The Saint Paul Hotel does not offer an on-site spa and recommends off-site providers (The Darling Den). Hotel Crosby lists a hot tub and rooftop terrace but no full spa in supplier listings.
The Saint Paul Hotel — it’s in downtown Saint Paul near Rice Park, Landmark Center, the Ordway and the Science Museum of Minnesota.
Hotel Crosby is not adults-only; it is family-friendly according to the supplied property information.
Explore how The Saint Paul Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·